Beautiful : perfect score from me.

Great sunset shot. There is still enough detail in the shot even though you were shooting right into the sun. I like the second person walking through the surf - makes it more interesting for me, and less staged I suppose.

good color and composition, in my opinion the sunset still is a relevant subject here!

imho, try another angle, so the silhoutte will look more dramatic as a PoI and you also can capture th waves

beautiful - reminds me of home.