Good alround score for this one. Just doesnt push my buttons for impact, B&W may have highlighted the detail/texture in the bricks better

Technically, compositionally, quality-wise, this is all good. That said, it doesn't really 'grab' me impact wise. High marks for everything else, though.

Very nice. I love all the texture created by the brick and the wood behind the window.

Very simple and very relevant. I love the off center composition.

Nice, I like the feel of this. I might have shown one more brick at the bottom, feels a bit tight to me. The shadow in the window is great and the strength of the brick texture also comes from shadows!!