A great illusion of a very big tree! or of very small camels? hum?...
High marks!

I think its beautiful. Obviously a big tree! Big beauty! Good job!

I'm not sure you've convinced me that this is a big tree. Those camels seem pretty far away, so they don't support the scale I think you're trying to imply. They're also competing with me for attention, which hurts the composition and the impact.

This is not doing it for me at all relevance-wise, but the camels on the horizon are great!

Here's your 9th rating...hope you make it to 13. :>)

Here's a big land where camels (very small camels from this perspective) are still used in commerce, at least so it appears.

Why do you leave so much space in the foreground where there is almost no detail or interest?

it's a good photograph..are those camels? the shot is deceptive with that tree! nicely done.

Not bad at all. You could really crop off a lot from the dark bottom though.