Browse Responses
‹ Newer | Up | Older ›

Response to Best black&white (Response #59)

Uploaded 316 Days Ago by mtmartini - 12 comments

Photo © mtmartini (Tracy Martin) - www.photo-sage.com/
Unauthorized reproduction not permitted.

User Comments

JimiThing said 316 days ago:

Whoo hooo! possibly cropped just a bit too tight.

Beamer said 316 days ago:

If it's topless, why do we only see the bottom half?
Cool image, I like it.

pursang said 316 days ago:

Very very clever. Neon is a difficult exposure challenge and you have nailed it well. I really like your choice of composition.

Ana said 315 days ago:

another fun shot.

ajcoutinho said 315 days ago:

Very original. High ratings.

mtmartini said 315 days ago:

Just for fun

Ratings Summary

* Relevance: 3.08
* Impact: 3.15
* Composition: 3.23
* Technique: 3.00
* Quality: 3.08
* Overall: 3.108

JimiThing said 315 days ago:

I see your scores and I just shrug my shoulders. I feel these scores are undeserving. Although I thought the crop was a bit off I still gave this shot mostly 4's and a 5 for impact. I still say this shot is way better than average. As are a few others that have yet to be featured.

mtmartini said 315 days ago:

The interesting thing for me is that while it is always nice to be featured, it is my images that don't feature that set a fire under my butt and make me ask myself the hard questions about what I could have done to make them better. It makes me more critical of my own work and in turn of others as well.

It is my so-called failures that really help me improve my eye but in the end it is a very personal thing - I posted that as a fun image to see where people stood on it. It scored higher than my blurred dancer image that just got published on onexposure - which is no small feat mind you. But I am just thinking aloud.

phototext said 315 days ago:

I like this, it's normally something you'de expect to see in colour, all garish and over the top but it works well in b/w.

Nice one.

phototext said 315 days ago:

If it came up in the members vote on OE I'd vote for it.

Hopefully my vote just bumped up those scores which under rate it in my opinion.