Response to Look Up (Response #39)

Uploaded 616 Days Ago by philippe - - 19 comments

Photo © philippe (philippe) - clairobscur.my-expressions.com
Unauthorized reproduction not permitted.

User Comments

XXIVXXV said 616 days ago:

great image. i'm sure it'll be up there. though i wish there was more definition in the shadows.

King said 616 days ago:

I feel compelled to give you high marks in every category for a photograph that I actually don't like. There is something very eye-catching in the thumbnail (like bombers over the S of L), but when I discover ducks flying in the wrong direction, I feel cheated. This isn't really a criticism. I'm trying to explain why I don't like this really good photograph.

King said 616 days ago:

Oh, yes...and it will probably be featured.

Ana said 616 days ago:

wow, is this the real lady?

browe said 616 days ago:

I don't think that the geese help the image.

dunny said 616 days ago:

very nice

Nick said 615 days ago:

Excelent. Just the right amount of detail in the shadows.

philippe said 615 days ago:

Thank you for your comments.
Well, King, what can I say? Maybe some kind of subconscious duck-phobia? :o)

King said 615 days ago:

@philippe...that's got to be it, but all WS commentors must express themselves honestly and, one would hope, kindly.

eggplant said 615 days ago:

Interesting to ponder this composition.

kadenajack said 615 days ago:

Nice. This is a unique take on Lady Liberty. Kind of Hitchcock-ish. Good work.

mikesphotog said 615 days ago:

good capture

photoflavor said 615 days ago:

wow. this is spectacular - what a moment to catch.

philippe said 614 days ago:

Thanks everybody, I really appreciate your comments and positive ratings. Not featured with a 3.7, times are difficult. :o)
I notice there are two contradictory comments about the shadows. I'd be interested to read further comments on that...
@King: do you mean my comment was unkind? Because that was not the idea. I'm asking this because sometimes the intention is not very clear in the words themselves. You try a joke and it's taken seriously by the reader.
On how people should or "must" express themselves, I think I'll try to answer on WS discussion group...

King said 614 days ago:

Philippe,
My meaning was that I did not intend to be unkind to you. I didn't know it was your photograph, of course, but it is not my favorite of your work.

This is a good photograph, but there is something about the geese/ducks that displeases me, I think.

My apologies for the misunderstanding.

King said 614 days ago:

Philippe,
Will you send me your e-mail address? I don't see it on your website.
king@kingdouglas.com

philippe said 614 days ago:

Don't apologize, it's MY misunderstanding. ;o)

I feel funny, because I'm talking with you on another matter in another discussion...
I really enjoy internet.

philippe said 612 days ago:

Phew,it took some time...
The funny thing is that it was featured at the exact moment I was opening it to check if I had missed some comments...

King said 612 days ago:

...but, then, what do I know?

Congratulations, mon ami!

You could comment on this photo if you were logged in.