Nice picture. I usually like simple graphic compositions. This is just a bit too simple, though.

This is very pleasing shot. I'd like for it to be a bit off center, instead of right in the middle.

I like this one. Looks like it was pushed pretty hard to boost the contrast, and the sky has gained noise through this process. I think you could crop a chunk off the bottom, and still maintain the impact.

There is certainly a nice density contrast here, but I think the vertical composition is less pleasing than the horizontal (with some room for the boat to move), but then you would lose that nice moon highlight. Still, good for the theme.

Great lightning.

I think this pic could have been much better without the white vertical stripe on the RHS - it's waaaaaay too distracting and cost at least 3 points in my rating.

I'm no fan of gratuitous Photoshopping, but either a bit of the clone brush, or a better crop is needed to improve this. The latter may not have been possible, given the aspect ratio of the image, so, PS it is!

amazing contrast, very high relevance.... lovely photo

Very nice, only one small picky comment: paint out the white stripe on the wall. 24/25, good job overall.