Browse Responses
‹ Newer | Up | Older ›

Response to Best black&white (Response #117)

Uploaded 302 Days Ago by AbsolutelyN - - 15 comments

Photo © AbsolutelyN - www.absolutelynothing.co.uk/
Unauthorized reproduction not permitted.

User Comments

phototext said 302 days ago:

Over the top but I still love it.

Cool.

nrcowlishaw said 302 days ago:

I get a really strange feeling that the moon was added, or the star trails? Am I wrong?

Ana said 302 days ago:

sure is cool!

Beamer said 302 days ago:

Very fake looking collage... The star trails, at this resolution, are very noisy, almost like they weren't shot continuously?? The moon is obviously way out of proportion to everything else. Sorry, this is not appealing to me.

AbsolutelyN said 301 days ago:

Yes this is very obviously a composite. The tree and stars are a single 75 mins exposure (breaks in trails are caused by cloud) and the moon is taken through a 1800mm focal length telescope. Just a bit of fun.

gazdi said 301 days ago:

A nice poster for most. A tipical good digital art score from me: low relevance and high impact.

gazdi said 301 days ago:

A nice poster for most. A tipical good digital art score from me: low relevance and high impact.

Nanate said 301 days ago:

I really like the thought in this. Very nice work with blending the layers.

JIMJIM said 301 days ago:

Well done and strong impact- is it a collage...?

Moses said 301 days ago:

This is an exceptional photo but it might be a bit too much. It edges towards the unreal.

Nick said 301 days ago:

I would like it without the moon.

AbsolutelyN said 301 days ago:

Thanks for all the feedback on this one - much appreciated.

It is interesting to hear the different opinions as I've always had really positive feedback to it in the past.

I guess it has just not to be taken too seriously as it is intentionally over the top, surreal and un-believable. At least it is not another dodgy HDR image that look much more fake that this to me :-)

kadenajack said 301 days ago:

I love this. I'm not sure how gazdi can defend a low relevance score. The theme is Best black&white and this is indeed black & white.

Sure it is manipulated and a composite, but it's a well executed one. Wish I had done it myself.

winetou said 301 days ago:

stunning ... great pic

gazdi said 300 days ago:

@kadenajack (and @AbsolutelyN): As I understood, subjectiv wanted to get b&w shots, one per post. This is clearly a collage, that's why I gave 2 for relevance. That 2 comes from the not that hard b&w conversions. All the other scores I gave was so high, because I like this post as it is - a wonderfully done collage of great shots.

You could comment on this photo if you were logged in.